Paper II
Question
Compare Radioactive Iodine and Carbimazole.
Answer
Compare Radioactive Iodine and Carbimazole
| Feature | Radioactive Iodine (I-131) | Carbimazole |
|---|---|---|
| Class | Radioisotope | Thioamide |
| Mechanism | Concentrates in thyroid via Na-I symporter, beta-emission destroys tissue | Inhibits thyroid peroxidase, blocking hormone synthesis |
| Onset | Slow (weeks) | Slow (weeks, since it blocks new synthesis, not release of stored hormone) |
| Outcome | Definitive — often causes hypothyroidism | Reversible — normal function can resume on stopping |
| Use in pregnancy | Absolutely contraindicated | Used with caution (PTU preferred in first trimester) |
| Relapse after stopping | Not applicable (permanent effect) | Common, especially after a short course |
| Suitability | Definitive treatment for Graves’/toxic nodular goitre, especially where surgery is contraindicated or medical therapy has failed | First-line medical therapy, particularly for a first episode or in younger patients wishing to avoid permanent treatment |
| Key adverse effect | Hypothyroidism (expected long-term outcome) | Agranulocytosis, hepatotoxicity |
Shared feature: both ultimately reduce circulating thyroid hormone levels, but by fundamentally different mechanisms (tissue destruction versus synthesis blockade), giving different onset, reversibility, and long-term outcome profiles.

